E&E Letters | Theatre costs are unrealistic

Over the past few weeks, the letters pages of Express & Echo have bee applauding some comments made by Cllr Peter Holland [CON, Pennsylvania] – this is my response to those views.
E&E Logo

 

Thursday 10 September 2105

Theatre costs are unrealistic

Yesterday I returned to Exeter after a day in Cardiff after preparing the sound equipment for the theatre tour of An Inspector Calls which starts in Dartford next.

I returned to see that your letters page contained yet another letter applauding the recent comments of Cllr Peter Holland who suggested that “the costs of a theatre in the city which could be in the region of £27m” [E&E, Exeter bus station pool critics argue theatre would be better for the city, 18 August 2015].

I won’t deny that a city-centre theatre could be built for about £27m – as this is the estimate from the Theatre For Exeter Development Group for a theatre with a capacity of between 800 and 1000.

So what I would challenge is that for £27m, Cllr Holland could deliver a 1200+ seater theatre capable of staging those large musicals he and many other correspondents seem to desire.

For the past 35 years I’ve worked in theatres across the country and around the world. During that time I’ve become used to turning dreams in reality – usually with little or no budget.

But a 1200-seat theatre for £27m on this development site – not even I can suspend that much disbelief.

I would suggest that at a minimum it would cost at least £47m to build such a theatre.

Councillors have already heard that we can cover the £26m project costs of the the new leisure complex without increasing our underlying need to borrow, and more importantly without increasing Council Tax of residents
I have been informed that Arts Council England are very unlikely to subsidise any new theatre build in the city, so that extra £21m WILL need to come from additional borrowing.

But with the cost of that borrowing relatively cheap for local authorities at the moment, that’s not the major problem facing anyone wanting to build a new theatre. The real financial burden is revenue costs – to actually run the theatre.

As a National Portfolio Organisation, Plymouth Theatre Royal receives revenue funding from Art Council England of £1.2m a year.

With ACE facing their own cuts from central government, I would suggest that it is very unlikely that any new venue in the city would receive anything like that amount of grant – especially as ACE already support many of Exeter’s arts organisations.

In addition, Plymouth City Council – as a unity authority – provide an annual subsidy the Theatre Royal to the tune of £600k pr year.

Plymouth Theatre Royal sees around half a million visitors a year – and many pay in excess of £50 a seat and still it needs massive amounts of subsidy.

Of course, there are other models of funding such theatres. Aylesbury Vale District Council pays a commercial operator – ATG – to run the theatre on their behalf. Yes, it’s cheaper – £350k a year – so could Cllr Holland or any of his Conservative colleagues tell me – and the residents of Exeter – which services they would cut to pay these sorts of sums?

So while I would love to see a such a theatre here in Exeter, I’ve looked at it from all angles for many years and still I can’t make the finances stack up. Every model costs ECC – and in turn, you the residents of Exeter.

That’s why I have supported the plan for a leisure complex, which will bring an income to the City Council.

With the leisure complex, we can ensure the health and well-being of our residents – while the income provided will ensure the health and well-being of the City Council.

And with that income, we can make plans for the future – perhaps even that 800 seater theatre elsewhere in the city centre?

 

Advertisements

2 thoughts on “E&E Letters | Theatre costs are unrealistic

  1. £70m could go on new theatre

    I see that the £70m plans for the bus station leisure centre “could put lives at risk” [E&E, 14 September 2015]. The increased traffic congestion in the surrounding read network won’t be helping anyone, including the emergency services.

    So Cllr Paul Bull [Theatre costs are unrealistic, Letters, 10 September], you obviously haven’t thought through support for your support for the leisure complex.

    The £70m that would have been used for the unwanted, unnecessary bus station plans can now be used for that much-much needed large central local theatre (at least 1200 seats, please).

    JV Whiting
    East Wonford Hill

    Like

  2. Many object to pool spending

    Your correspondent [Theatre costs are unrealistic, Letters, 10 September] writes a seemingly impressive letter (quoting estimated scary figures) detailing the impracticalities of building anything other than, not surprisingly, his party’s pool complex on the bus station site.

    However what he and his party seems to totally unable to comprehend is that many of us object to the huge amount of our money being spent on a project well over 90% of us will never use on the fictitious belief that it will bring thousands of people to Exeter who will be spending thousands of pounds. I would seriously like to know where all these people are coming from?

    Your correspondent also quotes that any such theatre would require an annual subsidy from the Council, but there again, if the estimated thousands to not turn up, so is the probability that the pool complex will also need some kind of subsidy. Think of all those January gym memberships cancelled in February.

    It does seem increasingly obvious that the Labour Council is pushing through a very expensive project that is not necessarily in the best interest – or more importantly, requirement – of the majority of the tax payers whose money they are spending.

    J Richards
    Exeter

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s